The Love Nest

Helen and Howard Cassidy had a stormy marriage. The couple separated three times and also had gotten divorced and remarried. By 1926 the marriage was on the rocks again. Helen took their five-year-old daughter and moved out without leaving a forwarding address. Howard moved back to his home state of Colorado with their two sons.

Helen and her daughter moved into the Anderson Hotel in Colton, just east of Los Angeles. The residential hotel was close to where her new love interest, William Johnston McLean, and his business partner planned to build 100 stucco homes inspired by Spanish architecture. McLean, a bachelor, was an Iowa-born real estate developer who’d also worked in Hollywood as an assistant director.

Anderson Hotel
Anderson Hotel in Colton, circa 1930

Meanwhile Howard Cassidy hired a detective to locate his wife and their child. The detective found Helen and the little girl living with McLean at the hotel. The newspapers described the couple’s abode as the “Colton Love Nest.”

Furious over what Helen had done, Howard brought suit against his wife and McLean for adultery and for contributing to the delinquency of a minor child. He also threatened to sue McLean for damages over alienation of Helen’s affections.

In this case that old adage should read: “Hell hath no fury like a man scorned.”

Adultery, defined as sex acts between a married person and someone who is not that person’s spouse, was a criminal offense in California at the time Helen and Howard were battling in the courts. The laws have since been changed and it’s currently only an “offense against public morals” in California. It remains a crime, at least on the books, in many other states.

Convicted of adultery just after Christmas 1927, Helen and McLean were sentenced to five to seven years each in state prison. Somewhat ironically, they were incarcerated in the same prison—San Quentin.

Howard sued for a divorce, which was granted while Helen was still locked up; He got custody of the couple’s three children. Helen requested that she be allowed to see her children after she was released from prison. According to her attorney, “She writes to me that she thinks she has atoned in full, under the execution of the sentence of the law, that a year in prison has changed her and that if she cannot see her three children her heart will break.”

The divorce court judge agreed that Helen had “atoned for her sins” and should be allowed to see the children “at any reasonable time” after she was released.

Helen was paroled from San Quentin after 14 months and McLean was released after 18 months. Prison has a way of souring even the most passionate love affair—the couple did not reunite after their terms were up.

McLean returned to L.A., where he no doubt carefully checked the marital status of his future girlfriends. Helen moved to an apartment by herself in Berkeley, just north of the UC campus. Hopefully Howard followed the judge’s orders and allowed his ex-wife to see the children regularly.

Featured photos: San Quentin prisoner photos of Helen Cassidy and W.J. McLean. California State Archives.

4 thoughts on “The Love Nest

  1. I’m in shock after reading this one! “Love nest” and “contributing to the delinquency of a minor” for two adults choosing to live together. Jail time for adultery!! I had no idea! And to think that some of your states still have adultery on the books as a crime?! Wow, but what a great story!

    I love this type of mugshot photo!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Kate! I’m not a legal scholar but sometimes I discover that there are still ridiculously out of date laws lurking around in America. I didn’t expect those laws to still exist in some states. So weird! Using a mirror to make mugshots at California state prisons lasted into the 1930s.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Shayne Davidson Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.